Urban Decay All Nighter dupes
setting-spray
By Viktoria @vioda.makeup · Published · Updated
My top pick to replace the $36 Urban Decay All Nighter is NYX Setting Spray at $9 — an 85% match that saves you $27. My favorite drugstore setting spray. Really locks makeup in. 1 more tested alternative is compared below.
You're overpaying $27 every time you buy the original.
Switch to the top dupe and save. If you buy 3 a year, that's $81 back in your pocket.
The original: Urban Decay All Nighter
Urban Decay All Nighter
$36
Long-lasting makeup setting spray.
Best Urban Decay All Nighter dupes
NYX Setting Spray
Save 75%$9
"My favorite drugstore setting spray. Really locks makeup in."
- + Good hold
- + Budget-friendly
- − Slightly less fine mist
e.l.f. Dewy Set
Save 83%$6
"Good for everyday; for all-night wear, go NYX."
- + Cheap
- + Dewy option
- − Less longevity
Side-by-side comparison
| Product | Price | Match | Best for | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Urban Decay All Nighter | $36 | Original | — | — |
| NYX Setting Spray | $9 | 85% | — | Save 75% |
| e.l.f. Dewy Set | $6 | 78% | — | Save 83% |
How the dupes compare
All Nighter is the gold standard for making makeup last. These get close.
Full comparison
Urban Decay All Nighter has earned its reputation as the setting spray that actually works—it produces a fine, even mist that locks makeup in place without feeling heavy or changing your finish. NYX Matte Finish Setting Spray is the closest drugstore alternative I've tested; the hold is genuinely impressive, though the mist nozzle produces slightly larger droplets so you need to hold it a bit farther from your face. e.l.f. Dewy Set takes a different approach with a hydrating, glow-enhancing formula that's better for dry skin or no-makeup-makeup days. Neither dupe delivers quite the same bulletproof lock as All Nighter in extreme heat or humidity, but for everyday wear they absolutely get the job done.
How long each one lasts
All Nighter keeps makeup locked for 10–16 hours in my experience, even in humid conditions. NYX holds strong for about 8–12 hours, which covers a full workday easily. e.l.f. Dewy Set gives around 4–6 hours of wear extension and works better for casual days than long events.
Frequently asked questions
Related dupes
Found your dupe? Check out more ways to save—or learn the looks that use these products.