MAC Spice Lip Pencil dupes
lip liner
Last updated: March 2026
You're overpaying $18 every time you buy the original.
Switch to the top dupe and save. If you buy 3 a year, that's $54 back in your pocket.
The original
MAC Spice Lip Pencil — Spice
$23
The original MLBB lip liner. A warm, brownish nude that defines lips naturally and works as a base for dozens of lipstick shades.
Shop originalMy top dupes
NYX Lip Liner Pencil in Natural
Save 78%$5
"The best MAC Spice dupe, period. The shade match is almost perfect and the formula is smooth enough to use as a full-lip base."
Best for: Everyone—this is a universal MLBB liner
- + Nearly identical shade
- + Smooth, creamy formula
- + Excellent price
- − Slightly softer—needs sharpening more often
Maybelline Color Sensational Lip Liner in Purely Nude
Save 65%$8
"Great option if you want more staying power. The shade is close but leans slightly cooler—works well on cool-toned skin."
Best for: Cool to neutral undertones, long-wear needs
- + Long-wearing formula
- + Prevents feathering
- + Built-in sharpener cap
- − Slightly less warm than Spice
- − Drier texture
At a glance
| Product | Price | Match | Best for | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MAC Spice Lip Pencil | $23 | Original | — | — |
| NYX Lip Liner Pencil in Natural | $5 | 90% | Everyone—this is a universal MLBB liner | Save 78% |
| Maybelline Color Sensational Lip Liner in Purely Nude | $8 | 84% | Cool to neutral undertones, long-wear needs | Save 65% |
Comparison notes
MAC Spice is a desert-island product for many. These dupes match the warm-nude shade that flatters nearly every skin tone.
Full comparison
MAC's Spice lip liner has been a makeup bag staple since the '90s—it's one of the most universally flattering nude lip liners ever made. The warm, brownish-nude shade works across a wide range of skin tones and pairs with everything from glosses to bold lipsticks. NYX's Natural liner is the closest match we've found: the shade is nearly identical, the formula is creamy and smooth, and the price is a fraction of MAC's. The Maybelline option is slightly cooler and drier in texture, but offers superior longevity—it won't budge for hours. Both dupes are excellent; the NYX is the shade match, the Maybelline is the wear-time winner.
Longevity
MAC Spice typically lasts 4–6 hours. NYX Natural wears for 3–5 hours. Maybelline Purely Nude can last 5–7 hours thanks to its drier, longer-wear formula.
FAQ
Related dupes
Found your dupe? Check out more ways to save—or learn the looks that use these products.