MAC Spice Lip Pencil dupes
lip liner
By Viktoria @vioda.makeup · Published · Updated
My top pick to replace the $23 MAC Spice Lip Pencil is NYX Lip Liner Pencil in Natural at $5 — a 90% match that saves you $18. The best MAC Spice dupe, period. The shade match is almost perfect and the formula is smooth enough to use as a full-lip base. 1 more tested alternative is compared below.
You're overpaying $18 every time you buy the original.
Switch to the top dupe and save. If you buy 3 a year, that's $54 back in your pocket.
The original: MAC Spice Lip Pencil
MAC Spice Lip Pencil — Spice
$23
The original MLBB lip liner. A warm, brownish nude that defines lips naturally and works as a base for dozens of lipstick shades.
Best MAC Spice Lip Pencil dupes
NYX Lip Liner Pencil in Natural
Save 78%$5
"The best MAC Spice dupe, period. The shade match is almost perfect and the formula is smooth enough to use as a full-lip base."
Best for: Everyone—this is a universal MLBB liner
- + Nearly identical shade
- + Smooth, creamy formula
- + Excellent price
- − Slightly softer—needs sharpening more often
Maybelline Color Sensational Lip Liner in Purely Nude
Save 65%$8
"Great option if you want more staying power. The shade is close but leans slightly cooler—works well on cool-toned skin."
Best for: Cool to neutral undertones, long-wear needs
- + Long-wearing formula
- + Prevents feathering
- + Built-in sharpener cap
- − Slightly less warm than Spice
- − Drier texture
Side-by-side comparison
| Product | Price | Match | Best for | Savings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MAC Spice Lip Pencil | $23 | Original | — | — |
| NYX Lip Liner Pencil in Natural | $5 | 90% | Everyone—this is a universal MLBB liner | Save 78% |
| Maybelline Color Sensational Lip Liner in Purely Nude | $8 | 84% | Cool to neutral undertones, long-wear needs | Save 65% |
How the dupes compare
MAC Spice is a desert-island product for many. These dupes match the warm-nude shade that flatters nearly every skin tone.
Full comparison
MAC's Spice lip liner has been a makeup bag staple since the '90s—it's one of the most universally flattering nude lip liners ever made. The warm, brownish-nude shade works across a wide range of skin tones and pairs with everything from glosses to bold lipsticks. NYX's Natural liner is the closest match we've found: the shade is nearly identical, the formula is creamy and smooth, and the price is a fraction of MAC's. The Maybelline option is slightly cooler and drier in texture, but offers superior longevity—it won't budge for hours. Both dupes are excellent; the NYX is the shade match, the Maybelline is the wear-time winner.
How long each one lasts
MAC Spice typically lasts 4–6 hours. NYX Natural wears for 3–5 hours. Maybelline Purely Nude can last 5–7 hours thanks to its drier, longer-wear formula.
Frequently asked questions
Related dupes
Found your dupe? Check out more ways to save—or learn the looks that use these products.