Too Faced Lip Injection Extreme Lip Plumper vs NYX Plump Shot Collagen-Infused Lip Serum
lip-gloss
Original
Too Faced Lip Injection Extreme Lip Plumper
$36
Bestselling lip plumping gloss that uses a tingling formula to temporarily volumize lips with a high-shine finish.
Shop originalDupe
NYX Plump Shot Collagen-Infused Lip Serum
$10
Save $26 (Save 72%)
"The closest drugstore match for the plumping effect. You feel the same tingle and see visible fullness — just at a fraction of the price."
Shop dupeMy verdict
NYX Plump Shot is a legitimate dupe for Too Faced Lip Injection Extreme — the plumping mechanism and overall experience are remarkably similar. Both use irritation-based vasodilation to temporarily swell the lips, both produce a visible tingling sensation, and both deliver a high-shine glossy finish. The main differences are intensity and longevity: Too Faced has a slightly more aggressive tingle and the plumping lasts about 30 minutes longer. But NYX gets you 85–90% of the effect for 72% less money. For the vast majority of people, the difference between the two won't justify a $26 price gap. If you're a lip plumper devotee who wants the absolute maximum tingle and swell, Too Faced remains the benchmark. For everyone else — especially those trying lip plumpers for the first time — NYX Plump Shot delivers the experience without the premium.