Merit Lip Oil vs NYX Lip Oil
lip-balm
Original
Merit
Merit Lip Oil
$28
Non-sticky lip oil with subtle tint.
Dupe
NYX
NYX Lip Oil
$10
Save $18 (Save 64%)
"Close feel and finish."
My verdict
NYX's Lip Oil delivers a surprisingly similar glossy, nourishing finish at a third of the price. The hydrating effect is comparable — both leave lips feeling soft and conditioned rather than sticky. NYX's shade range is different but includes close matches to Merit's most popular shades. The main trade-off is longevity: Merit's formula lingers slightly longer and reapplies more seamlessly. For everyday use, the NYX dupe is an excellent value. For special occasions or if you prefer the sleeker packaging, Merit is worth the splurge.