Benefit Hoola vs Physician's Formula Butter Bronzer

bronzer

Original

Benefit

Benefit Hoola

$32

Matte bronzer for contour and warmth.

Shop original

Dupe

Physician's Formula

Physician's Formula Butter Bronzer

$16

Save $16 (Save 50%)

"A fan favorite. Very similar effect to Hoola."

Shop dupe

My verdict

Physician's Formula Butter Bronzer is the best bronzer dupe in beauty—and many people actually prefer it to Hoola. The coconut-scented, buttery formula blends like a dream and gives a natural, warm glow. Hoola is more matte and slightly better for contouring; Butter Bronzer is warmer and more glowy. For the price difference ($10 vs $30), the Butter Bronzer wins for everyday bronzing. Use Hoola if you specifically need a cool-toned matte contour.

FAQ

See full dupe guide with all alternatives