How to Stop Mascara From Smudging Under Your Eyes
By Viktoria @vioda.makeup ·
Mascara that ends up under your eyes by noon is almost always fixable—and rarely the mascara's fault alone. It's usually oil, a wet under-eye, or technique. Here's how to keep it exactly where you put it.
How to stop mascara smudging and giving you raccoon eyes: formula choice, setting the under-eye, curling and coating technique, and fixes for oily lids, watery eyes, and humidity.
Figure Out Why It's Smudging
Mascara migrates for a handful of reasons, and the fix depends on the cause. Oily lids and skin transfer mascara upward onto the lid and down under the eye. Watery eyes or oily under-eye skin break down the formula from below. Long or downward-pointing lashes brush against the skin and stamp mascara there every blink. And skincare or concealer that's too heavy or not set gives the mascara something slick to slide into.
So before blaming the product, notice where it lands and when. Smudges on the lid point to oil up top; smudges underneath point to a wet or oily under-eye and lashes touching skin. Most people have a mix, which is why the fixes below stack.
Choose and Prep the Right Formula
If you smudge constantly, a waterproof or 'smudge-proof' formula is the most direct fix—waterproof mascara resists the oil and moisture that break down regular formulas, though it takes more effort to remove at night. A tubing mascara is another great option: it coats each lash in a polymer tube that stays put through oil and tears but slides off easily with warm water.
Even a great formula smudges on a wet base, so let mascara dry completely before you look down at your phone or apply anything else near the eyes. And curl your lashes before mascara, never after—curling lifts them away from the skin so they stop brushing your under-eye and cheek with every blink.
Set the Under-Eye and Lid
This is the step that fixes most smudging and the one people skip. After concealer, set the under-eye with a small amount of finely milled powder so there's no slick, creamy surface for mascara to transfer onto. A dry, powdered under-eye is far harder to smudge onto than a dewy one, no matter how oily your skin runs.
Do the same on oily lids: a touch of powder or an eyeshadow primer up top stops mascara from migrating onto the lid crease. If your under-eye still smudges, try using less concealer there—a heavy, unset layer of concealer is often the real culprit, not the mascara at all.
Apply Mascara So It Stays
Wipe excess product off the wand before each eye—a wand overloaded with wet mascara deposits more than the lash can hold, and the overflow ends up on your skin. Apply thin coats and let each dry before adding the next, building length and volume in layers rather than one gloopy pass.
Focus most of the product on the upper lashes and go light on the lower lashes, which sit right against the under-eye skin and are the number one source of smudges. If you do coat the lowers, use the tip of the wand and the tiniest amount, or skip them entirely and let your uppers do the work. For downturned lashes, wiggle the wand at the roots and sweep up and outward to keep them off the cheek.
Fixes for Humidity, Watery Eyes, and Quick Touch-Ups
In heat and humidity, waterproof or tubing formulas plus a well-set under-eye are non-negotiable, and a final mist of setting spray over the finished face helps hold everything. If your eyes water easily, dab—don't rub—the inner corner with a tissue as needed and lean on a waterproof formula that won't run when they do.
When a smudge does happen, don't wipe it and smear it. Let it dry fully, then flick it away with a clean, dry cotton swab or a small fluffy brush, and touch up the concealer underneath if needed. A dry smudge lifts off cleanly; a wet one you rub just spreads into a grey shadow across your under-eye.
FAQ
More from the blog
How to Stop Concealer From Creasing Under Your Eyes
Concealer that settles into fine lines by mid-morning is almost always too much product on a dry, unset base. Here's the prep-and-set method that keeps under-eyes smooth all day.
How to Brighten Tired Under-Eyes With Makeup
Bright, awake-looking under-eyes aren't about piling on concealer—that's what causes the creasing and grey cast most people fight. The trick is color, the right shade, and a whisper of product in the right place.
How to Do Makeup in Cold Weather (So It Doesn't Flake, Crack or Run)
Cold air and indoor heating dry skin out from both sides, so the base that looked fine in September starts flaking by December. Here's how I change my routine for winter, step by step, from prep to the lip that has to survive a scarf.